Saturday, May 24, 2014

NESTLE LANKA(NEST.N0000) AGM Highlights(2014-05-22)

It's being a while since I made the last post here. Mainly due to recent changes in my work place.  Anyway thought of writing a short not about NEST AGM which I attended last week. Nestle AGM was held on 22-05-2014 at Sri Lanka Foundation Institute, Colombo 07.



As always NEST AGM is very investor friendly. For those who are interested, there was a free health check for share holder followed by Breakfast Cereals, Refreshments and a couple of foods trucks serving(LoL!).

 

Anyway I was not there for the food and drinks, but it is a gesture of goodwill towards the share holders and worth mentioning. I've been a long standing share holder of NEST. The purpose of this post is to share some important points raised by share holders as well as the answers given by management.

Shareholder Concerns & Answers

  •  DPS is not there in the 10 Year summer : Personally I too have been annoyed by this. Without this data it is difficult to draw graphs you will see at the end of this post.
  •  Suggestion subdivide shares and increase liquidity : One share holder make this suggestion and said that will raise the dividend yield for share holders (which is incorrect). Later on Mr Ganesan Ampalavanar (Managing Director) also explained that and said they have no plans for a subdivision. I also believe that it is pointless to go for a subdivision just to increase the liquidity as long as the price stability is there.
  • Minimum Free Float : This is not a big concern for NEST. As market capital of NEST is over 5 billion they need to shed only 0.28% of shares to fall inline with the rules. Management explained that they have time till 2016 to do that and even after that they can appeal for more time.
  • Break up of amount of money paid to farmers : Page 5 of annual report says 4.8 billion was paid for raw material purchases. I too was keen to know the break up (dairy and coconut). I know that as a policy Nestle do not give any hints about their business segments. That may be the intention of one who asked the question. Management said that they will consider this. But I don't think that they will give those information. It is true that this data is important for share holders but we have to remember that it is also important for competitors as well.
  •  Reintroduce "Nespray" Brand : Some felt that "Nespray For Every Day" as a degraded product. Currently Nestle do not produce or import Full Cream Milk Powder. I think this is a strategic decision by the management as explained on next point. 
  •  DCD issue : Some informed shareholders praised the management for the way they handled the issue. As explained by the management, Non of the products have been tested positive and they have completely stopped importing milk power. Currently Nestle is the largest milk purchaser in the island and all products are locally sourced. This might be the reason for discontinuation of Nespray. I think the profit margins are higher on other products where company have the price control(government have imposed a price ceiling for milk powder in SL). Also it is important to not that management said that if they were opportunistic, they could have destroyed the competitors during the crisis last year(not on those words Lol!). 
  •  Complementary Gifts : Management categorically rejected the proposal of giving gifts for share holders in order to preserve the share values. Yeah! be a good share holder not a greedy share holder.

Dividend History of NEST


I said that I'm a long term investor of Nestle. If you need a reason Why? Following graph explain it very clearly.




Here is a gain/loss simulation of NEST from 2001. It is important to note the difference between annual gain with(1300%) and without(350%) dividend reinvesting.



Conclusion

If you too attended the AGM and have anything else to add or if you have some concerns about the content, you may comment below. I will try my best to answer you.

Happy Investing!

6 comments:

  1. Hi dileep,
    Thank you for wonderful update. Presently PE stands at 30 which is very high compare to their parent PE but relatively cheaper compare to Pakistan and India PE of Nestle. What would be your thoughts if u want to start investing in Nestle Lanka from now on? I want to enter.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is true that PE valuation of NEST is bit high. But I think currently NEST is fairly valued.
      Even a conservative Graham formula gives around 2350/= (60*(7+(18*1.8)))
      #EPS : 60, No Growth P/E Base : 7, 10Year Growth Rate : 18%
      Personally I see no risk of entering at current price level.

      You may also have a look at this too.
      http://www.cse.lk/cmt/upload_report_file/487_1399888835728.pdf

      Delete
    2. Too much of consolidation happening around 2100 level. It is not going anywhere.

      Delete
    3. Historically NEST price has been following a step function pattern.
      Usually the price go up with the September(3Q) results.
      Report will be out in next couple of weeks.
      We will see what happen this year.

      Personally, I'm bluish on NEST.
      YTD gain is just 5%, lower than ASI gain of 22%.
      1Q & 2Q EPS is Rs.38/=. This is a 18% increment with compared to last year.
      I'm expecting Rs.20/= for 3Q & Rs.24 for 4Q.
      In terms of dividends, Rs.80/= for FY2014 ( a 33% increase).

      Delete
  2. Hi Dileepa, could you please send me the updated screener? Thank you. my email id is kkronline@gmail.com.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Karthikraja,

      I updated DB on 2014/07/21. You can use the download link on following article.
      http://colomboinvestmentjournal.blogspot.com/2013/12/colombo-stock-exchange-share-screener.html?showComment=1399034107082#c238767229140345096
      Or here is the direct download link :
      http://www.mediafire.com/view/svua39hi3cddgnc/CSE_Screener_1_4_1_20140721.xlsm

      Regards,
      Dileepa

      Delete